Human trafficking

Human Trafficking in the United States, Canada, and Latin America

Every year, traffickers generate more than $150 billion in profits by victimizing millions of people worldwide. Vulnerable and susceptible to manipulation, children and youth experiencing homelessness are a prime target of this lucrative and criminal industry.

Two main factors drive the spread of human trafficking: high profits and low risk. Like drug and arms trafficking, human trafficking is a market-driven criminal industry based on the principles of supply and demand. No country is exempt from this illicit enterprise.

Across the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Central America, where Covenant House provides residential programs and vital services to children and youth facing homelessness, the most common form of human trafficking is commercial sexual exploitation. Its primary victims: young women and girls.

Why Do Human Traffickers Target Kids Facing Homelessness?

In our long experience helping more than 1.5 million vulnerable children and youth in North and Central America, Covenant House has identified a direct correlation between youth homelessness and becoming a victim of human trafficking. 

Why do human traffickers target kids facing homelessness? Because these young people present a low-risk business proposition and are relatively easy to lure from the streets with promises of love, protection, food, and financial security. Because of their vulnerability, children and teens with no place to call home and no one to care for them make easy prey for traffickers. 

"I was on the street in the winter and there was no soles on my shoes. A pimp saw me and said he would help me out. He said he would buy me three pairs of shoes. I couldn't believe he was going to buy me shoes. I was freezing; I didn't know what else to do."
 

It isn’t long, though, before traffickers show their true intentions. At Covenant House -- in the safe houses and safe spaces across our movement -- we witness firsthand the physical, emotional, and psychological toll human trafficking takes on these young victims. 

As one of our case workers says, “Trafficking is more than selling sex. Trafficking is young people being physically and sexually assaulted. Trafficking is torture. It means victims being kept up for days. It means forced starvation. Recovery for victims is long and complicated, and takes the efforts of a lot of good people.”  

What Else Do We Know About Human Trafficking Among Children and Teens?

• Most human trafficking victims are not in chains. Instead, pimps may use psychological and emotional coercion that is just as effective. Many victims become traumatically bonded to their pimps; despite enduring horrific violence, they believe their pimps love them. Cases of Stockholm syndrome among victims of human trafficking are not uncommon.
• Traffickers also may exert control over their young victims by giving them drugs to create dependency, confiscating their identification and money, withholding food or sleep, and isolating victims from their families and friends, among other tactics.
• Human traffickers exploit the lack of available beds in youth homeless shelters. They manipulate the young and homeless by telling them that shelters are full and promising them a soft bed elsewhere. 
• Young people facing homelessness often have to make the desperate choice between sleeping on the street or going with a pimp who offers them food and shelter. Faced with dire situations like this, these young people are easily manipulated into becoming victims of human trafficking.
• According to U.S. federal law, there is no such thing as a “child prostitute,” and any child under age 18 engaging in commercial sex is, by law,  a victim of sex trafficking. Despite this, far too many children are sexually exploited and do not know how to escape the vicious cycle. 
• If a pimp forces a person to engage in sex for money against their will at any time, whether through threats, coercion, or physical violence, that person is a human trafficking victim, regardless of age or initial consent.
• While women and girls are most often detected as victims of sex trafficking, boys fall victim to trafficking, too. Just like girls, the exact number of trafficked boys is unknown; and boys are often less likely to ask for help.
• LGBTQ youth experiencing homelessness are at especially high risk for human trafficking victimization. 
• Traffickers deny their victims independence, education, and the ability to gain employment skills. This may intensify the desperate feeling of human trafficking victims that they have no way out.
• If societies want to fight human trafficking, they cannot afford to cut services for young people experiencing homelessness.

Covenant House Is on the Front Lines Against Human Trafficking

Because so many young victims are homeless before being trafficked, they often have no place to go after escaping the bonds of this modern form of slavery. That's why Covenant House remains a refuge for these children and youth  – offering a complete approach that includes direct care, advocacy, and research, to ensure we can best serve young trafficking survivors.

Direct Care

Direct care allows us to make the greatest and most immediate impact in the lives of young trafficking survivors. All of our houses across the United States, Canada, Mexico, Guatemala, Honduras, and Nicaragua provide refuge to human trafficking survivors. Two of our sites, New York and Toronto, have established distinct housing programs dedicated to supporting trafficking survivors, and our site in Honduras includes a safe house exclusively for girls who have been trafficked, abused, or sexually exploited. Our direct care for human trafficking survivors includes the following:

• Intake Screening Tools
• Personal Care Kits
• Safe House/Safe Space Programs
• Holistic Care/Therapies
• On-site Case Management
• Mental Health Care
• Trauma-informed Approach

Providing direct care fuels groundbreaking research, which allows us to refine our programmatic methods and tools. Covenant House New York helped pioneer methods for screening youth for trafficking experiences. Today, new screening tools developed by Covenant House New Jersey and Covenant House Texas, in collaboration with respected researchers, are helping us to more quickly identify trafficking survivors and provide them the special care they need. Our direct care also makes us better advocates for service, funding, and laws that protect children and youth from the horrors of human trafficking.

Advocacy

Across our movement, Covenant House partners with like-minded organizations and community advocates to act as a powerful voice for justice, funding, and services for human trafficking survivors. 

In the United States, we are proud to be part of the strongest anti-trafficking coalition in the country, and have successfully fought for safe harbor laws and to close the legal loophole that had allowed online marketplaces to advertise young people for sex. In Canada and Latin America, we support victims through the grueling process of testifying against their traffickers in court. In Guatemala, we bring to court strategic legal cases that affect policy concerning exploited and trafficked youth and provide psycho-judicial support for the girls and young women who testify. In Toronto, we supported the girls whose testimonies led to Toronto’s first-ever human trafficking conviction.

Human Trafficking Research

Research is critical to understanding the intricacies of human trafficking and the scope of its impact on victims. But victims often are reluctant to or prohibited from coming forward, making it challenging to collect accurate data that could help put a stop to this criminal industry.  

Covenant House, with nearly half a century providing trusted and transformative care and shelter to young people facing homelessness across the Americas, is uniquely positioned to advance research into human trafficking and its impact. Our research exposes the toll of human trafficking on children and youth, continually updates and improves our practices of care, and informs our advocacy efforts to protect all young people, especially children and youth experiencing homelessness.

Several Covenant House sites have collaborated with exceptional research partners to unite our experience to their analytical expertise and produce groundbreaking studies with impact. Below are details from our most recent research projects, with links to the full reports.

1. Prevalence and Nature of Human Trafficking among Youth Experiencing Homelessness in the United States and Canada

From February 2014 to March 2017, Covenant House invited researchers from Loyola University (New Orleans) Modern Slavery Research Project (MSRP) and The Field Center for Children’s Policy, Practice & Research at the University of Pennsylvania to 13 cities across the United States and Canada to serve as external experts to study the prevalence and nature of human trafficking among young people experiencing homelessness. The result has led to one of the largest-ever data sets on human trafficking and exploitation experiences of youth facing homelessness.

Here are some of the key findings from the studies.

From MSRP’s study, of 641 young people interviewed:

• 19% were identified as victims of some form of human trafficking
• 14% were victims of sex trafficking 
• 8% had been trafficked for other forced labor.

From The Field Center’s study, out of 270 young people interviewed:

• 20% had been sex or labor trafficked
• 17% were victims of human trafficking
• 6% were victims of labor trafficking.

Read the full texts of the Loyola and Penn studies here.

2. Risk Factors for Human Trafficking Among Youth Facing Homelessness in New Jersey

In 2015 to 2017, Covenant House New Jersey, in partnership with Mount Sinai, conducted a separate longitudinal study of 344 youth experiencing homelessness who sought services at our houses in Atlantic City, Elizabeth, and Newark. The study explored the factors that differentiate trafficked homeless youth from not-trafficked homeless youth in order to determine risk and protection factors for human trafficking among New Jersey youth facing homelessness. 

The New Jersey study found the following.

• Young people facing homelessness who have a supportive adult in their life had lower odds of being trafficked.
• A history of having an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) or 504 Plan, indicative of having a learning disability or related challenge, was an unexpected factor significantly associated with a trafficking experience. 
• Gender was not associated with a trafficking experience. 

These and other findings from the research can be found in the peer-reviewed journal article by Chisolm-Straker, Makini, et al., “A Supportive Adult May Be the Difference in Homeless Youth Not Being Trafficked,” Children and Youth Services Review, vol. 91, 2018, pp. 115-120, doi:10.1016/j.childyouth.2018.06.003. 

Read the full text of the Covenant House New Jersey and Mount Sinai study here.  

3. Attitudes and Behaviors that Put Teenage Girls at Greater Risk of Sex Trafficking in Canada

In April 2018, Covenant House Toronto partnered with IPSOS Public Affairs to survey and interview teenage girls across Canada to better understand the attitudes and behaviors that put the teens at risk for sex trafficking. The qualitative part of the research consisted of one-on-one interviews with sex trafficking survivors, their parents, and advocates, as well as online mini-groups with teenage girls, ages 12 to 16, and parents. The quantitative survey, which was informed by the qualitative study results, polled 501 girls between the ages of 12 and 16 in rural communities and urban centers across the country.

The Canada study found the following.

• Early teenage years are a critical age range in which to educate girls before their risk for human trafficking increases. Girls with greater familiarity with the term sex trafficking were more likely to take steps to ensure their safety. They were also more likely to be confident they would know if they were being “catfished,” that is, deceived by someone using a fictitious identity, online.
• Education about sex trafficking and open dialogue between girls and their parents are important for reducing the risk that a girl will be trafficked for sex. Girls who report that their parents are aware of their online social media activity or feel that they can talk to their parents about anything expressed greater awareness of the risks of certain behaviors and greater aversion to engaging in many of those risky behaviors. Parents play a critical role in keeping their daughters safe from human traffickers.

Read the full text of the Covenant House Toronto and IPSOS Public Affairs study here. 

What Would You Do?

It is hard to imagine yourself or your child in a position of such vulnerability that you become a target for human traffickers. We invite you to try to do just that, by taking our quiz. Walk in the steps of a young person experiencing homelessness and, at each turn, consider what you might do. Click this link to begin the journey.

Additional Resources:
“Global Report on Trafficking in Persons,” United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), 2018; “Global Estimates of Modern Slavery,” International Organization of Labor, 2017; “I am Jane Doe,” a documentary by Mary Mazzio.